Why Ignorance Trumps Knowledge In Scientific Pursuit

People looking at the scientific world from the outside often see it as one dominated by facts, where scientists use a stepwise, systematic process that begins - you know, you learned all this stuff in grade school, a hypothesis, the collection of data, of observations, blah, blah, blah, you go through all these steps.

In his new book, Ignorance: How It Drives Science, Neuroscientist Stuart Firestein says in fact science is a fishing expedition propelled by what scientists don't know and produces more questions than answers, as it should. He also teaches a class on ignorance at Columbia University, where he is professor and chair of the Department of Biological Sciences. Below is a radio interview with the author from NPR.

Download file "Ignorance.mp3"



0 comments

Put Away The Bell Curve: Most Of Us Aren't 'Average'

For decades, teachers, managers and parents have assumed that the performance of students and employees fits what's known as the bell curve — in most activities, we expect a few people to be very good, a few people to be very bad and most people to be average. But new research argues that a lot of people are actually outliers. The researchers found that most people are not average, but below average, and that there are a small group of high achievers or performers. To learn more listen to the following story.


Download file "Put Away The Bell Curve.mp3"







0 comments

No 'God Particle' Yet

Physicists have a grand theory that describes how tiny particles interact to form all the stuff we see in the universe — everything from planets to toasters to human beings.

But there is one particle predicted by this theory that has never been detected in experiments. It's called the Higgs boson. The Higgs boson is a famous subatomic particle first theorized to exist back in the mid-1960s. It's a key part of some beautiful mathematics that would explain a fundamental mystery: why things have mass. Scientists are dying to know if it really exists — and now researchers are closer to finding out than ever before.

If the Higgs is not found in the next year or so, he says, scientists may have to totally rethink their ideas about the inner workings of the universe.


To learn more listen to the story below from NPR.







0 comments

entry

This is placeholder text for your new blog entry. Replace it with your own.

0 comments

No 'God Particle' Yet, But Scientists Say Stay Tuned

This is placeholder text for your new blog entry. Replace it with your own.

0 comments

Scientists Report Breaking The Speed Of Light, But Can It Be True?

The AP is reporting results from a group of Italian researchers using equipment from the European Organization for Nuclear Research (CERN) that claims they've measured particles traveling at a speed greater than the speed of light.



If this result were true (it has not been published, and thus not peer-reviewed, yet) then the structure of the world might be very different from what we believe. Einstein's theory of relativity is built on the idea that there is an absolute cosmic speed limit — that light is the thing traveling at this speed is beside the point. Among other things, the existence of that speed limit sets the structure of causality in the Universe.

In other words, that effects follow causes and not the other way around, which is, in general, a good thing. The universe would be a whole lot harder to understand without this link between cause and effect. Think of it as being shot before the trigger is pulled. It's more nuanced than what I am describing here (of course) but breaking light-speed means breaking relativity and causality as we know it flows from relativity.

So if these results are correct then we might have to go back and start rebuilding pretty much all of modern foundational physics. Are they correct? This kind of thing has been claimed before. My colleague Steve Manly who works with neutrino beams in experiments like the ones described by the AP story puts it this way, "I'm not planning to eliminate the relativity portion of my general physics course anytime soon."

Based on past experience, these results are probably wrong but it sure would be a wild ride if they prove correct.


Reported by Adam Frank who is an Astrophysicist

0 comments

Giant Camera Will Hunt For Signs Of Dark Energy

A giant and powerful digital camera is about to be shipped from a lab near Chicago to a telescope in Chile to study a mysterious part of the universe called dark energy.

Dark energy makes up most of our universe, but scientists currently know almost nothing about it except that it seems to be making the expansion of our universe speed up.

"There's enough data that people know what we don't understand, but there's not enough data to explain it yet," says Brenna Flaugher, a physicist at Fermilab near Chicago, which assembled the Dark Energy Camera. "There's too much room for the theorists to come up with crazy ideas right now. And so there's lots of crazy ideas. And we need data."

Story by Nell Greenfieldboyce

For more listen to the NPR story below.






1 comment

Why Seeing (The Unexpected) Is Often Not Believing

Two psychologists have been conducting experiments on inattentional blindness — how people fail to see things in front of them when they're focused on something else. They were inspired by a case in which a police officer said he didn't see a crime in progress even though he ran past it.





0 comments

Are Math Skills Built In To The Human Brain?

Psychologist Véronique Izard discusses a study that suggests Amazonian villagers with no math schooling are just as equipped to solve basic geometry problems as math-trained adults, and cognitive neuropsychologist Brian Butterworth talks about the arithmetic cousin of dyslexia, dyscalculia.








0 comments

The 'Decline Effect' and Scientific Truth

Surprising and exciting scientific findings capture our attention and captivate the press. But what if, at some point after a finding has been soundly established, it starts to disappear? In a collaboration between Radiolab and On The Media, NPR looks at the 'decline effect' when more data tells us less about scientific truth.















0 comments

Bob Dylan's Words Find Place In Legal Writings

NPR"S Robert Siegel talks to Alex Long, University of Tennessee law professor who contends that Bob Dylan's song lyrics are used more than any other writer's in court opinions and briefs. He chronicles the artist's influence on today's legal community. From U.S. Supreme Court rulings to law school courses, Dylan's words are used to convey messages about the law and courts gone astray.








0 comments

entry

This is placeholder text for your new blog entry. Replace it with your own.

0 comments

entry

This is placeholder text for your new blog entry. Replace it with your own.

0 comments

Study: America's Wealth Not Widely Distributed

One percent of the U.S. population owns approximately 40 percent of the nation's wealth. That's a distribution that most Americans don't know about, Dan Ariely of Duke University discovered in a recent study. Respondents of all demographic categories mistook Sweden's even wealth distribution for that of the United States.


Download file "America's Wealth.mp3"

0 comments

The problem of the reduction of social data to numerical from

Education advocates point to a recent spate of test scores that show the United States falling behind other nations. But what's the real story?

Most of the latest test-score coverage focused on the sky-high Shanghai results. But those numbers don't say much about Chinese education system overall. Shanghai is a talent magnet that's showered with government spending. It just doesn't represent the whole country. Therefore, we shouldn't panic about international comparisons. A new Brookings Institution report shows that the United States ranked 11th out of 12 countries when the first international math tests were given way back in the 1960s. Further, the recent scores show that the U.S. actually improved modestly in test scores.

Ben Wildavsky's article on the myths and realities of global education in the new issue of Foreign Policy put it this way “We do have a smaller piece of the educational pie, but the pie has gotten much bigger. And that's good. We shouldn't fear that other countries' educational gains come at our expense. Knowledge crosses borders and benefits everyone. Yes, we must improve. But we're all better off in a better-educated world”.








0 comments

entry

This is placeholder text for your new blog entry. Replace it with your own.

0 comments

Beauty, elegance and intuition

I went to Cal Tech yesterday to hear a lecture by the mathematician Dr. Yau. He spoke about his new book, The Shape of Inner Space: String Theory and the Geometry of the Universe’s Hidden Dimensions. We have been covering art and beauty in TOK the last few weeks and one of the important ideas is that mathematics, physics and the arts have a lot in common. Students usually think that the subjects are polar opposites when it comes to our search for truth and knowledge, but from my perspective this is not the case. Dr. Yau used the words beauty, elegance and intuition numerous times during his lecture. These words are often associated with the arts and not mathematics. He spoke of the beauty and elegance of Calabi-Yau Manifolds which he help develop and the spark of intuition that led him to his discoveries. Below is a beautiful picture of a Calabi-Yau Manifold.





0 comments

Beauty, elegance and intuition

This is placeholder text for your new blog entry. Replace it with your own.

0 comments

Does anyone know what time is?

Today, I went to Cal Tech to hear Sean Carroll, a theoretical physicist, talk about his new book From Eternity to Here. His new book is about the nature of time, the beginning of the universe, and the underlying structure of physical reality. His lecture was far ranging and covered many topics that we have discussed in theory of knowledge, including hard determinism, free will and reductionism. Sean Carroll contends that all of our explanations about reality must be compatible with the laws of physics. He believes that genuine properties, like free will, emerge out of complex systems. He also believes that their explanations must be compatible with the basic laws of nature. Below is a link to Carroll talking about his book on the Colbert Report.
Sean Carroll

0 comments

"the map is not the territory"

Following A Wandering North Pole

The location of the magnetic North Pole is moving toward Siberia at about 40 miles per year and every few hundred thousand years, the North and South poles switch positions entirely. Geophysicist Ronald Merrill explains what's known about the inner workings of the Earth's magnetic field. Ronald Merrill’s description of the inner working of the Earth’s magnetic field reminded me of the paradox of cartography. The cartographer’s paradox states that if a map is to be useful, then it must of necessity be imperfect. I remember being taught that you can think of the magnetic field as a bar magnet at the center of the Earth that is tilted about 10 degrees with respect to the rotation axis. Ronald Merrill explains that this is a simplified description of a far more complex and fascinating phenomenon. We still have much to learn about the Earth's magnetic field.




0 comments